Best Premier Yarn for Plushies: My Honest Review of 5 Popular Options
- Crystal Barger
- Apr 28
- 6 min read
Quick disclosure: Premier Yarns did not sponsor or pay for this post. Everything here is my own opinion from my own experience. Some links in this post are affiliate links, which means I may earn a small commission if you purchase through them at no extra cost to you. I’m an affiliate because I actually use and love their yarn, not because someone told me to say nice things. Pricing and availability can change, so double-check the listing before you buy.
If you’ve been trying to figure out the best Premier yarn for plushies, this post breaks down the differences so you can choose the right one for your project.
Pest Premier Yarn for Plushies
Premier has quite a few yarns that work well for plushies, but not all of them shine in the same way. Some are better for chunky, cuddly makes. Some are better for smaller details. Some are gorgeous but need a little patience. So instead of giving you the usual vague “this one is soft and nice” rundown, here’s my real take on a few Premier yarns that are worth looking at for plushie making.
If you make plushies, you already know the yarn matters almost as much as the pattern. The wrong yarn can turn a cute idea into a frustrating mess real fast. The right yarn, though, can make your plushie soft, squishy, and honestly hard to put down.
Parfait Chunky is probably one of the easiest places to start if you want soft, huggable plushies that work up fast. It has that thick, velvety feel plushie makers love, and the bulky weight helps projects come together a lot quicker than smaller yarns. This is considered a super bulky 6 yarn, but, I feel it's on the thinner side and leans closer to Bulky 5, in my opinion. I usually use a 5 mm crochet hook for this one.
What I like most about this line is the large amount of available colors to choose from. The yarn is always soft and it gives plushies that rounded, squishy look. It is especially good for amigurumi, plush animals, and anything you want to feel extra cuddly.
Best for: plushies, beginner-friendly projects, quick makes
What to know: This is the one that’s more likely to shed and, if you yank a magic ring too hard, snap on you like it has a personal vendetta. Treat it gently and give your joins a little extra love. (Plush is usually a bit more forgiving than Chunky.)
Price: $4.99
Material: 100% polyester chenille (#6 super bulky)
Size note: smaller skeins than Basix and Parfait Plush (100 g / 3.5 oz)
Yardage: 131 yds / 120 m
Colors: 72
Reviews: 4.7 out of 5 (2,010 reviews)
My recommended hook: 5 mm
If your goal is maximum softness and larger plushies, Parfait Plush is a strong contender! This yarn has a fluffier, more velvety finish that makes finished plushies feel extra cozy. It gives that classic stuffed-animal softness people instantly want to touch.
I like this one for projects where size matters. If you want a plushie to feel luxurious and extra snuggly, this is a good yarn to consider. This is their newest line of plush yarns and it is for sure, one of my favorites! It is very similar in size to Bernat Blanket.
Best for: Ultra-soft plushies, cuddly gifts, baby-friendly feeling projects, creates chonky large plushies
What to know: Plush is thicker and comes in larger skeins than Parfait Chunky, and it tends to be a little more durable in my experience. Still chenille though, so it can shed.
Price: $7.99
Material: 100% polyester chenille (#6 super bulky)
Size note: larger skeins than Basix and Parfait Chunky (200 g / 7 oz)
Yardage: 174 yds / 160 m
Colors: 30
Reviews: 4.7 out of 5 (135 reviews)
My Recommended Hook Size: 6.5 - 7 mm
This line is a fun one if you want bold color and that soft chenille texture without overthinking it. The Brights are great for playful plushies, while the Multis can add interest without needing color changes.
For plushies, this kind of yarn is great when you want something soft but still vibrant. The color options can do a lot of the visual work for you, especially with simpler shapes.
Best for: Colorful plushies, playful character designs, projects that need visual interest without complicated colorwork
What to know: Basix chenille is more Bernat Blanket-ish in vibe (to me), with less shedding and a sturdier feel than Parfait. If Parfait makes you want to throw your hook, Basix might feel like therapy.
Price: $3.99
Material: 100% polyester chenille (#6 super bulky)
Size note: bigger skeins than Parfait Chunky (150 g / 5.3 oz for solids)
Yardage: Solids 112 yds / 103 m, Multis 75 yds / 69 m
Colors: 55
Reviews: 4.7 out of 5 (544 reviews)
My Recommended Hook: 6-7 mm
This line stands out because the colors feel a little more curated and trend-forward. If you like plushies that look cute and modern and not just bright for the sake of being bright, this one is worth a look.
The chenille softness is still there, but the palette gives it a different vibe. These shades feel more intentional, which is great if color selection is part of your brand or aesthetic.
Best for: Modern color palettes, trendy plushies, makers who care a lot about the overall look of their finished pieces
What to know: Same general Basix vibe, just with colors that feel hand-picked (because they are). Perfect if you want consistent, aesthetic photos without spending 20 minutes deciding which pink is “the right pink.”
Price: $4.99
Material: 100% polyester chenille (#6 super bulky)
Size note: same skein size as Basix solids (150 g / 5.3 oz)
Yardage: 112 yds / 103 m
Colors: 14
Reviews: 5.0 out of 5 (2 reviews)
My Recommended Hook Size: 6-7 mm
Cotton Sprout® DK
Now if you are making smaller amigurumi or you want crisp details, Cotton Sprout is a totally different experience from the plush yarns above. This is the one I would reach for when I want better stitch definition, cleaner shaping, and more control.
It’s a better fit for detailed work, smaller pieces, and projects where structure matters. Plush yarn is adorable, but sometimes you need to actually see what you are doing, and this is where a DK cotton yarn can really shine. The photo below is actually an example made with Premier Cotton Fair Bulky, not Cotton Sprout, but it still gives you a good idea of the cleaner, more defined finish you can get from cotton yarn.
Best for: Detailed amigurumi, smaller plushies, pieces with shaping or finer features
What to know: This is cotton. It is not going to give you a marshmallow-soft chenille look. But for details, stitching, and not wanting to guess where your hook is entering, it is often the superior option. Also note that this yarn is harder to work with if you have issues with your hand. Because it's 100% cotton, it has less stretch, if this is an issue but you still want to work with cotton yarn, try their Cotton fair Worsted or Bulky. Cotton fair is a cotton/acrylic mix and is a little bit easier on the hands.
Price: $4.99
Material: 100% cotton (#3 light weight)
Yardage: 230 yds / 210 m
Colors: 42
Reviews: 4.9 out of 5 (288 reviews)
My Hook Recommendation: 2mm
So Which One Should You Choose?
It really depends on the kind of plushie you want to make.
If you want a soft, cuddly yarn with a huge color selection, go with Parfait Chunky.
If you want extra plush, stuffed-animal softness, try Parfait Plush.
If you want bright, playful color, Basix Chenille Brights and Multis are a solid choice.
If you want stylish color palettes, the Mama Made Minis collaboration is especially fun.
If you want smaller details and cleaner stitch definition, Cotton Sprout DK is probably the better fit.
Final Thoughts
There is no single perfect yarn for every plushie. Annoying, I know. But Premier does have some really good options depending on the look and feel you want.
For me, the best plushie yarn is not just about softness. It is about how easy it is to work with, how the finished shape looks, and whether the yarn actually fits the project I have in mind. Some yarns are better for quick, chunky plushies. Some are better for smaller, more detailed makes. Knowing the difference saves a lot of frustration and probably a little rage.
If you are trying Premier yarns for plushies, I would start with the one that matches your project style best, not just the one with the prettiest color. Pretty yarn can still humble you.
And rude yarn absolutely will!
Comments